Everton player was scolded by manager in dressing room after bizarre moment inspired iconic win

Some 30 years ago today, Tottenham Hotspur were thrashed 4-1 in an FA Cup semi-final at Elland Road with a stunning display that Joe Royle insists: “is still one of the best performances I’ve seen from an Everton side.” That stellar showing, that was the high-point on the Blues’ road to Wembley glory with the 1-0 victory over Alex Ferguson’s Manchester United for what remains their last major honour to date, also represented one of the most-enjoyable trips for Evertonians at a ground where they had long suffered against home side Leeds United.
On April 9, 1995, though, the construction that season of a new 17,000 capacity East Stand – the biggest cantilever stand in the world at the time – saw fans from north London housed there, while the other three sides of the ground were filled by Blues supporters, ensuring Everton dominated proceedings both on and off the pitch. Speaking on his episode of Goodison Park: My Home, Royle, who celebrated his 76th birthday yesterday, told the ECHO: “The game against Spurs at Leeds, is still one of the best performances I’ve seen from an Everton side. I say that with no bias at all.
“We were terrific that day. From the first minute, we were up and at them.
“It wasn’t a fluke, it wasn’t a one-day wonder, it wasn’t that Tottenham were awful on the day. We were terrific.”
Everton went ahead on 35 minutes with a header off a corner kick from right-back Matt Jackson – who had netted the winner at Bristol City in the fourth round – while Graham Stuart doubled their advantage 10 minutes into the second half after Ian Walker could only parry a shot from Paul Rideout into his path. Also speaking on Goodison Park: My Home, Stuart told the ECHO: “It’s still, to this day, my favourite game I’ve ever played in.
“The occasion, it was brilliant. We turned towards Elland Road, and it was just a sea of Everton.
“You couldn’t see any Tottenham fans. The fans absolutely played their part, they bossed it off the pitch.
“Then, when it came to the game, we bossed it on the pitch. I’ll never forget running out, we had three sides of the ground, and as you ran out of the tunnel, Tottenham had the brand-new stand.
“We had the real atmosphere. It felt like a home game.
“From minute one, we just dominated the game. It was an unbelievable start for us, with Jacko, near post, a flicking header to put us one nil up.
“We came in at half-time and it was ‘come on lads, you’re 45 minutes from an FA Cup final, let’s dig in, don’t give anything away.’ We hadn’t conceded a goal in the cup run, all the way through.
“Ian Walker scuffed his kicks to Ridders (Paul Rideout), who ran through and I just followed it up. Walker saved it but it was an open goal and I couldn’t miss.
“I tapped it in and off we go, two nil. We knew then, the likelihood was that we were going to win the game.
“Then we got the dodgy penalty (Teddy Sheringham fell over when Dave Watson beat him to an aerial challenge) given against us and Jurgen Klinsmann stepped up and scored it. They had a two-minute spell when they came at us and Nev made a great save, Stuart Nethercott struck it and Neville saved it with his legs I think, but then we literally went up the other end, broke away and scored.”
Everton’s last two goals, in the 82nd and 90th minutes, came from Nigerian international Daniel Amokachi who had taken it upon himself to enter the action when Rideout was down receiving treatment in what Royle quipped was “the best substitution I never made.”
Recalling his proactive way of entering the fray in 2021, Amokachi told the ECHO: “I was pumped up and I knew before the game if I had the opportunity I would take it because the last few weeks before we played Tottenham I’d really been on fire in the reserves. The captain Dave Watson, Neville Southall, Joe Parkinson, they all saw it.
“But when the gaffer had said to give Rideout ‘five more minutes’ I felt that inside he still didn’t have that confidence in me yet. I gave the substitution slip to the fourth official, the ball went out of play and I get jumped into the team.
“Joe came running towards the touchline saying: ‘What are you guys doing?’ I looked at him, fixed my collar, and ran on to the pitch.
“Minutes later I was on the scoresheet, then again soon after. I didn’t break the news of what happened to the world, the gaffer did in press conference.
“He came into the locker room and told me: ‘Well done – and never try that s**t again!’”