Tottenham 1 Aston Villa 2: Another early Spurs exit, Emery’s depth delivers and Richarlison’s injury
Following a dispiriting period that produced just one win in six Premier League games, an FA Cup third-round tie against Aston Villa offered Tottenham Hotspur a chance to breathe new life into their campaign.
A cup run last season — all the way to glory in the Europa League — rescued a dismal 2024-25. So could they use this match to inject some impetus into Thomas Frank’s first season in charge?
Unfortunately for Spurs and their head coach, they came up against a Villa side which had won 12 of their previous 14 games in all competitions and which have designs on finishing this campaign with a trophy of their own.
Emi Buendia put the visitors ahead with a powerful drive at the end of a well-worked team move and Morgan Rogers doubled their advantage in first-half stoppage time.
That might have broken the home team, but Spurs actually dominated for long periods in the second half and showed the kind of fight that will have heartened Frank.
Wilson Odobert’s excellent low finish after 54 minutes prompted a long period of Spurs pressure but they could not find a way through against a resilient Villa side, who held on to reach the fourth round. To add to Tottenham’s problems, forward Richarlison limped off with an injury early in the first half.
Jack-Pitt Brooke, Elias Burke and Conor O’Neill analyse the key talking points from the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.
What happened to Spurs’ love affair with the FA Cup?
There are many different ways to show Spurs’ decline in recent years, but one of the clearest is in the FA Cup.
Tottenham used to be synonymous with this competition, but they have not won it since 1991. Under Harry Redknapp and Mauricio Pochettino, they would often reach semi-finals but then fail at the penultimate hurdle. Now they do not even do that.
Tottenham have not gone beyond the fifth round of the FA Cup since 2018, a quite remarkably poor record for one of the bigger teams in the country. But in the past seven seasons before this one, all of their exits were in the fourth or fifth round. This is the first third-round exit since 2014, when Tim Sherwood was in charge.
Spurs desperately needed a cup run this year. They are already out of the League Cup, they are going nowhere in the Premier League and the serious end of the Champions League will be beyond them. This would have been their only route to excitement, their only chance to compete for something and try to rebuild some of that much-needed unity between players, fans and coach.
Now that must wait for another year.
Jack Pitt-Brooke
Squad-depth issues? Villa’s fringe players deliver again
Villa’s squad is the thinnest of the Premier League’s three title challengers, but those on the fringes continue to make their mark.
Unai Emery showed how seriously he takes this competition, making just four changes from the side that drew 0-0 in midweek against Crystal Palace. Among those who came in, Donyell Malen and Buendia both, once again, strengthened their case to start more often.
Malen has more goals as a substitute than any other player in the league this season (three), and deputising for Ollie Watkins at centre-forward, he was lively, linking play and running the channels.
He provided a superb assist for Buendia’s opener, which came from a sweeping Villa move through the middle of the pitch. Receiving the ball at the edge of the area, Malen jinked inside and played a disguised reverse pass for Buendia to slam home.
Buendia, who has twice scored from the bench in the league, then provided an assist of his own, this time a delicate backheel for Rogers after some excellent wide play from Malen. He was unlucky not to add another goal in the second half, after Tottenham defender Pedro Porro cleared his effort off the line.
Emery will want greater depth added in January as Villa fight on three fronts, but performances like this suggest the squad is more than capable of stepping up.
Conor O’Neill
Can Spurs take hope from their second-half display?
The strange thing about watching Tottenham this season is that so many of their performances have been so bad that it is easy to get over-excited about occasional better spells. When the general level of the team is so poor, even competence looks like brilliance.
That said, the second-half fightback in this match was still one of the better halves of football Spurs have produced recently. They raised the tempo, started winning the ball back high up the pitch, created chances and got back into the game.
Odobert scored early in the second half and Spurs continued to take the initiative. Xavi Simons was excellent, helping his team to drive through the middle of the pitch. Odobert and Mathys Tel kept Villa pinned back down the sides and Randal Kolo Muani showed more presence than normal up front. Spurs, for once, looked like a competent, unified, hard-working team.
Of course, it was not enough and Spurs still lost the game. But it made for a very different second half, and a different feel at the end. This will not go down as one of the most painful, embarrassing defeats of their season. It will actually go down as one of the less bad ones.
And maybe — if you take this second half in an optimistic light — it gives a basis to build on.
Jack Pitt-Brooke
How damaging might Richarlison’s injury be for Spurs?
After missing 45 matches for club and country last season, Richarlison’s fitness record has been one of the very few bright sparks under Frank. With Dominic Solanke unavailable for most of the season and Kolo Muani still adjusting to English football, at least the Dane has had the Brazilian fit and available to rely on to lead the line.
Unfortunately, however, after Richarlison pulled up holding his hamstring inside the Villa box in the 27th minute, it appears he is set for a period on the sidelines again.
After Brennan Johnson departed for Crystal Palace on January 2, Tottenham have lost their current top goalscorer for this season and last season’s leading marksman in just over a week. Add Son Heung-min leaving for LAFC in the summer, and Frank is now without Spurs’ top goalscorers from the 2023-24, 2024-25 and 2025-26 seasons. Solanke did make his return as a second-half substitute, offering some encouragement, but a side already short on goals can ill-afford to lose any more.
It adds to an already crowded treatment room. Mohammed Kudus has been ruled out until after the March international break after sustaining a quad injury against Sunderland last weekend. He was joined on the sidelines by Lucas Bergvall and Rodrigo Bentancur, who missed the Villa game after sustaining injuries in the 3-2 defeat by Bournemouth on Wednesday.
Tottenham were much better in the second half, with Kolo Muani helping to connect attacks from the striker position, but attacking reinforcements are desperately needed.
Elias Burke
What next for Spurs?
Saturday, January 17: West Ham (Home), Premier League, 3pm UK, 10am ET
What next for Villa?