Tottenham Hotspur – a power vacuum in which chaos and misery are thriving
It has been a grim week for Tottenham Hotspur, littered with unwanted setbacks and distractions, and suggesting their unhappy season could quickly descend into further misery.
Spurs squandered leads against Sunderland and Bournemouth, and lost Mohammed Kudus, Lucas Bergvall and Rodrigo Bentancur to injuries.
Kudus is set to be sidelined until March having pulled up in Sunday’s 1-1 home draw with Sunderland, two days after his understudy, Brennan Johnson, was sold to Crystal Palace.
Adding insult to injury, the 3-2 defeat at Bournemouth on Wednesday was bookended by the sight of head coach Thomas Frank drinking out of an Arsenal-branded coffee cup, and defenders Pedro Porro and Micky van de Ven testily clashing with travelling supporters. Then came club captain Cristian Romero’s quickly-edited outburst on social media, appearing to accuse the club’s hierarchy of “lies”.
On Friday, the Tottenham Hotspur Supporters’ Trust (THST) released a statement, expressing frustration over “the embarrassment” in Bournemouth and the lack of leadership from senior figures at the club, who “should address these issues publicly and through direct communication with fans”.
Defeat at home to Aston Villa in the FA Cup’s third round on Saturday evening would add to the gloom and increase the apathy of hopelessness which is rapidly gripping large swathes of the fanbase.
Last winter, Spurs were eliminated from both domestic cups, including a 2-1 defeat at Villa in the FA Cup’s fourth round, in successive games four days apart in early February amid an unenviable injury list and spiralling Premier League form – but even so were considered favourites for the Europa League, which they of course went on to win.
This year, they are still in the Champions League, sitting 11th in the 36-team table with two of the eight rounds of league-phase games to play later this month, but nobody gives them a hope in hell of winning that.
Frank’s innocent mistake of sipping his pre-match brew from a cup left at the Vitality Stadium by Arsenal when they played there four days earlier was meaningless, but the incident still threatens to dog the Dane, only adding to the sense that he can do no right in the job he took last summer.
It was the kind of misstep that could only happen to an already-floundering general, akin to a hapless MP sitting on the wrong side of the House of Commons, and has been gleefully seized upon by Arsenal fans.
Frank has far bigger problems, however, and Romero’s post-match outburst on Instagram was further evidence of the defender’s emotional and unpredictable behaviour.
The post questioned why “other people” at the club were not fronting up, claiming it “has been happening for several years” and adding that they “only show up when things are going well, to tell a few lies”.
He later edited the post to remove the line about “lies”.
Frank has described Vinai Venkatesham as “one of the best communicators I’ve ever met” but supporters have heard relatively little from the club’s new chief executive, save for a series of chats with in-house media. Even then, his most recent interview with club channels was in October, lauding the return of Fabio Paratici as co-sporting director.
As for Paratici, he has now been offered a return to his homeland with Fiorentina and was conspicuous by his absence when Frank listed Spurs’ leadership team to reporters on Friday – “Johan (Lange, the other sporting director), Vinai and I are very aligned, ownership is very aligned,” he said – casting further doubt on the Italian’s future. Paratici, incidentally, regularly spoke to the media while at previous club Juventus, but has been seen rather than heard during his two spells at Tottenham.
Meanwhile, the true power at the club — majority owners the Lewis family and non-executive chairman Peter Charrington — remain shrouded in mystery, their vision and strategy for Spurs largely opaque, save for a few one-liners distributed via a third party. They are probably still inconspicuous enough to pass most supporters in the street without prompting a backward glance.
“We reiterated to the club that we believe the club leadership should address these issues publicly and through direct communication with fans,” read THST’s statement on Friday. “We stressed that fans need to hear directly from the club leadership the ambition for the football club for this season, for next season, and for the foreseeable future.”
Silence from the top was a feature under former executive chairman Daniel Levy before his shock firing in September but this was supposed to be a new, more open era, characterised by fresh ambition and accountability. Instead, the hierarchy has changed but the frustrations of the supporters, and indeed the players, remain the same.
Romero has taken aim at his paymasters before, saying in December 2024, after a defeat to Chelsea when Levy was still in office, that “it’s always the same people responsible” for the problems at Spurs.
Frank confirmed on Friday that Romero had been spoken to rather than fined and, from the outside looking in, the club are appearing to treat the Argentina international with kid gloves, perhaps wary of alienating one of their few real stars.
Frank’s command of the dressing room has already been questioned, given his side’s listless performances and the incident when he was blanked by Van de Ven and full-back Djed Spence following another defeat to Chelsea in November, and now his captain’s outburst and the club’s response to it threaten to further undermine his authority.
He alluded to Romero’s questionable suitability as skipper on Friday, describing the 27-year-old World Cup and two-time Copa America winner as a “young leader”. Romero’s Instagram post came just a couple of weeks after he was sent off late in the 2-1 home defeat against Liverpool for kicking out at Ibrahima Konate – an act of petulance which hampered Spurs’ chances of snatching a draw against meek opposition.
He will miss the cup game against Villa after admitting to an FA charge of “acting improperly by failing to leave the field of play promptly” following that dismissal, resulting in an additional one-match ban.
Frank selected Romero to wear the armband after Son Heung-min’s summer departure to Major League Soccer but might reasonably point out that he had little choice; there are few other compelling captaincy options in this squad.
It is clear that Spurs miss Son, both as a unifier in the dressing room and a conduit with fans, while the absence of Levy as a lightning-rod for supporter dissatisfaction over the past few months has also increased the scrutiny on Frank and his players, and left a hole at executive level that the club are still working to fill.
Tottenham will inevitably need time to recover from such high-profile departures, but if there is hope that their current malaise can be quickly reversed, it may come in this weekend’s opponents.
Unai Emery has transformed Villa’s fortunes since his appointment in October 2022 without dramatically overhauling the squad, taking them from the bottom three to the top three and demonstrating that a visionary coach who improves players can quickly make up for perceived shortcomings both above and below him in the chain of command.
If Frank is to prove himself to be that man for Spurs, he cannot afford too many more missteps — unfortunate or otherwise.